Tuesday, March 18, 2008
Second Amendment Arguments
The US supreme court heard arguments on the constitutionality of the DC ban on handguns today. With J.Kennedy siding with the ban opponents, in all likelihood, the ban will be struck down. However, whether a reasonableness standard under which the scope of the restriction on arms ownership will be determined is not so clear. Also, I was somewhat surprised that most judges seemed to concur that machine guns will not be covered - given that even the Solicitor General Clement conceded that 'keep and bear' refers primarily though not solely to military use, it seems to me that machine guns have a stronger case to be protected by the second amendment than hand guns do. It is likely that some of the liberals including J. Stevens and J. Breyer who pointed that out may come out in support of the ban though I do not expect him to actually pronounce that machine guns are okay. It seems for now that individual self-defense and use of arms for hunting will end up being protected with even conservative judges allowing restrictions to apply to more dangerous weaponry which is ironical given that the plain language of the Second Amendment seems to make clear exactly otherwise, i.e., the chief concern pertained to national defense through a civilian army. Anyway, more when the opinion is actually pronounced.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comments:
Hi,
Sorry for this unsolicited comment. But I found you from the "lawandotherthings.blogspot.com" and have a question on related topic. I need the opinion from some one in the law community.
A friend of mine suggested to have a database of the set of Indian Laws (IPC etc..) online in a form similar to Wikipedia. In my friends vision, the database
- will put the laws in simpler language that is easily understandable to common man
- will interpret the laws (may be provide examples of what cases the law is applied)
- will be in multiple Indian languages
My question is,
1) will he be able to find some group of lawyers, law students, lecturers or professors who would be willing to interpret the law, simplify it and post it to that website? If so, where? Main point is, there is no money to pay!
2) Is there one such thing available already?
3) Will you, your friends or your college faculty be interested in doing such an initiatve?
if you want, you may mail me at badhrij attt gmailllll dotttt commmm
Thanks and again sorry for the unsolicited scrap.
Post a Comment